The Biggest Successes and Failures for All 30 MLB Teams in 2025

As the 2025 Major League Baseball (MLB) season approaches its conclusion, teams are reflecting on their journeys throughout the year. Each franchise has experienced its share of highs and lows, from breakout performances to disappointing underachievements. Here’s a look at the biggest successes and failures for all 30 MLB teams this season.

American League East

Baltimore Orioles

**Biggest Success:** Trevor Rogers
Despite the Orioles’ overall struggles, pitcher Trevor Rogers has emerged as a significant bright spot. After starting the season in the minors, he has excelled in the majors with an impressive 8-2 record and a 1.43 ERA over 16 starts.

**Biggest Failure:** Adley Rutschman
Rutschman has had a disappointing season, failing to meet expectations as one of the top catchers in baseball. His performance has been marred by injuries, and he has not contributed significantly to the team’s success.

Boston Red Sox

**Biggest Success:** Pitching Acquisitions
The Red Sox have benefited from the performance of new additions like Garrett Crochet and Aroldis Chapman, both of whom have excelled on the mound, with Chapman on track for a career-best ERA.

**Biggest Failure:** In-Season Roster Management
Despite strong rookie performances, the Red Sox have struggled with in-season acquisitions, ranking low in their ability to replace injured players.

New York Yankees

**Biggest Success:** Bronx Bombing
The Yankees have made a name for themselves with their power-hitting lineup, with over half of their runs coming from home runs. This offensive firepower keeps them competitive in the postseason race.

**Biggest Failure:** Devin Williams
The addition of reliever Devin Williams has not gone as planned, with his ERA ballooning to 5.30, significantly impacting the bullpen’s effectiveness.

Tampa Bay Rays

**Biggest Success:** Junior Caminero
The young third baseman has had a breakout season, hitting 44 home runs, second in franchise history for a player his age.

**Biggest Failure:** Close Games
The Rays have struggled in tight matchups, with a poor record in one-run games, which has hindered their overall performance.

Toronto Blue Jays

**Biggest Success:** Ernie Clement
Clement has been a versatile player for the Blue Jays, contributing significantly on both offense and defense, helping the team maintain its strong record.

**Biggest Failure:** Jeff Hoffman
Hoffman has had an inconsistent season as the primary closer, blowing several saves and struggling to maintain effectiveness.

American League Central

Chicago White Sox

**Biggest Success:** Rookie Contributions
The White Sox have seen substantial contributions from their rookie players, which has provided a foundation for future success.

**Biggest Failure:** Luis Robert Jr.
Robert has not lived up to expectations, with injuries and poor performance affecting his season.

Cleveland Guardians

**Biggest Success:** Stretch-Run Rotation
The Guardians have seen a resurgence in their rotation, significantly improving their ERA in the final stretch of the season.

**Biggest Failure:** Offensive Struggles
Cleveland’s offense has been lackluster, ranking near the bottom in multiple offensive metrics, which has hampered their playoff aspirations.

Detroit Tigers

**Biggest Success:** Tarik Skubal
Skubal has continued to impress, replicating his previous Cy Young-winning form and becoming a key player for the Tigers.

**Biggest Failure:** Rotation Depth
While Skubal has excelled, the rest of the rotation has struggled, raising concerns about the team’s pitching depth.

Kansas City Royals

**Biggest Success:** Starting Pitching
The Royals have developed a strong rotation, ranking among the best in the league.

**Biggest Failure:** Inconsistent Offense
Despite strong pitching, the Royals have struggled to score runs consistently, limiting their chances for success.

Minnesota Twins

**Biggest Success:** Joe Ryan
Ryan has emerged as a top-tier pitcher, increasing his innings and improving his performance significantly.

**Biggest Failure:** Midseason Unloading
The Twins’ decision to trade away key players has led to a poor record, disappointing fans and affecting attendance.

National League East

Atlanta Braves

**Biggest Success:** Hurston Waldrep
Waldrep has shown promise as a young pitcher, contributing positively to the Braves’ rotation.

**Biggest Failure:** Overall Season Performance
The Braves are on track to miss their preseason forecast by a significant margin, leading to widespread disappointment.

Miami Marlins

**Biggest Success:** Emerging Lineup
The Marlins have developed an exciting lineup featuring young talent that bodes well for the future.

**Biggest Failure:** Rotation Injuries
Injuries have plagued the Marlins’ pitching staff, preventing them from reaching their potential.

New York Mets

**Biggest Success:** Juan Soto
Soto has performed well, demonstrating his value despite the team’s struggles.

**Biggest Failure:** Collapsing Rotation
The Mets’ pitching staff has seen a significant decline, impacting their ability to compete in the league.

Philadelphia Phillies

**Biggest Success:** Kyle Schwarber
Schwarber has had a historic season, joining the 50-homer club and leading the league in RBIs.

**Biggest Failure:** Aaron Nola
Nola’s performance has been disappointing, with a high ERA impacting the team’s pitching depth.

Washington Nationals

**Biggest Success:** James Wood
Wood has stood out as a bright spot in a challenging season, showcasing his potential as a future star.

**Biggest Failure:** Rebuilding Process
The Nationals’ rebuild has not progressed as planned, leading to ongoing struggles on the field.

National League Central

Chicago Cubs

**Biggest Success:** Offensive Production
The Cubs have maintained one of the most potent offenses in baseball, showing depth and versatility.

**Biggest Failure:** Bullpen Uncertainty
The lack of a reliable bullpen has raised concerns as the playoffs approach.

Cincinnati Reds

**Biggest Success:** Strong Rotation
The Reds’ starting pitchers have performed well, keeping the team competitive.

**Biggest Failure:** Offensive Regression
Despite early promise, the Reds’ offense has faltered, failing to meet expectations.

Milwaukee Brewers

**Biggest Success:** Brice Turang
Turang has emerged as an All-Star-caliber player, contributing significantly to the Brewers’ success.

**Biggest Failure:** Late-Season Injuries
While the team has performed well overall, injuries in the bullpen could pose challenges in the playoffs.

Pittsburgh Pirates

**Biggest Success:** Paul Skenes
Skenes has continued to impress, establishing himself as a key player for the Pirates.

**Biggest Failure:** Anemic Offense
The Pirates have struggled to score runs, significantly impacting their overall performance.

St. Louis Cardinals

**Biggest Success:** Matthew Liberatore
Liberatore has shown promise, making strides in his development as a pitcher.

**Biggest Failure:** Lack of Direction
The Cardinals have struggled to establish a clear path forward, leading to a disappointing season.

National League West

Arizona Diamondbacks

**Biggest Success:** Geraldo Perdomo
Perdomo has had a breakout season, establishing himself as a key player for the Diamondbacks.

**Biggest Failure:** Rotation Performance
The team’s starting rotation has not met expectations, impacting their overall success.

Colorado Rockies

**Biggest Success:** Attendance
Despite their struggles, the Rockies have maintained decent attendance figures.

**Biggest Failure:** Overall Performance
The Rockies are facing their third consecutive 100-loss season, raising questions about their future.

Los Angeles Dodgers

**Biggest Success:** Yoshinobu Yamamoto
Yamamoto has been a reliable presence in the rotation, contributing to the Dodgers’ success.

**Biggest Failure:** Health Issues
Injuries have plagued the Dodgers, complicating their path to a potential repeat championship.

San Diego Padres

**Biggest Success:** Trade Deadline Moves
The Padres made impactful trades that helped bolster their roster during the season.

**Biggest Failure:** Xander Bogaerts
Bogaerts has not lived up to expectations, struggling offensively since joining the team.

San Francisco Giants

**Biggest Success:** Revamped Lineup
The Giants have put together a competitive lineup that has kept them in playoff contention.

**Biggest Failure:** Defensive Metrics
Despite some strong individual performances, the team’s overall defense has been below average.

Seattle Mariners

**Biggest Success:** Cal Raleigh
Raleigh has made history with his home run totals, establishing himself as a top catcher.

**Biggest Failure:** Rotation Underperformance
The Mariners’ rotation has not lived up to preseason expectations, impacting their playoff chances.

Texas Rangers

**Biggest Success:** Resilience Amid Injuries
The Rangers have thrived despite significant injuries to key players, showing depth and determination.

**Biggest Failure:** Home Offense
The team has struggled offensively at home, impacting their overall performance.

Miami Marlins

**Biggest Success:** An Emerging Lineup
The Marlins have developed an exciting lineup featuring young talent that bodes well for the future.

**Biggest Failure:** Rotation Injuries
Injuries have plagued the Marlins’ pitching staff, preventing them from reaching their potential.

Key Facts

– The Baltimore Orioles’ Trevor Rogers has a 1.43 ERA in the majors.
– Kyle Schwarber of the Philadelphia Phillies leads the league with 128 RBIs.
– The New York Yankees have scored 59% of their runs via home runs.
– The Arizona Diamondbacks’ Geraldo Perdomo is having a career year at shortstop.
– The Colorado Rockies are facing their third consecutive 100-loss season.

Source: www.espn.com